I am very blessed to live in a Catholic diocese which has lots of priests and churches, all within a five minute drive. To date, I’ve not met a “bad” priest. Each is likely doing his best to live out his vocation, share his faith and lead those entrusted to his care.
As for their ability to preach, this varies greatly. That’s not unique to this part of the country. Rather, it’s a blind spot for much of the Catholic Church in the United States. We’ve put entirely too little attention to the skill of preaching. As a result, the quality is spotty and one week, you may enjoy a great homily while the next week could leave you scratching your head.
As for those who try and downplay the importance of the priest’s message during Mass under the guise of “we’re not here to be entertained”, I call BS. This is actually a smoke-screen for those that have a limited understanding of the human experience of Mass.
While we don’t need a laser-light show when we worship or vegan cookies in the narthex after Mass, a good parish (and their priests) understand the value of hospitality, music, and yes, good preaching. They don’t ignore it out of respect for the people.
Think about it- an “average” Catholic will go to Mass once or twice a month. The homily is likely to be the only bit of spiritual encouragement they’ll receive all month. They are not being encouraged via social media or the internet or their favorite news website. As a result, the homily is of vital importance. And, within a Catholic context at least, there is so much emphasis on personal sin and evil that the homily is critically important for speaking and encouraging word.
That brings me to the wisdom of a 13 year old, my 13 year old.
At a recent Mass for her Catholic school, it was clear that the priest was promoting a sort of therapeutic moral deism- God is out there and wants you to be nice. I doubt the priest (who is actually a super nice man) even knew that he was preaching in this way. After all, we give our priests so little feedback that it’s hard for them to know that they are doing a good (or bad) job.
Later that day, my daughter commented on the priest’s message in this way, “Our priests need to get some new messages! It’s the same thing over and over- be nice, be polite, listen to your mom and dad.”
What was she really saying?
In my mind, she was calling for help. As a 13 year old in a Christian home, she knows that it’s important to be nice and to listen to her parents. The challenge is HOW to do this and how to go beyond niceness into personal discipleship.
Isn’t this the goal, after all?
A personal relationship with Christ that transforms our lives?
A lifestyle that looks different from those of others?
An ethic of living that desires to help others in need?
My 13 year old was echoing, though she didn’t know it, an ache found in many of us. We need less what and more HOW. We know God loves us. Show me what that looks like. We know that prayer is important. Show me how to do it. We know that the Church can be a force for good. Show me how the People of God can make a practical difference in the world.
For Follow Up
This is going to be challenging for most of us but I encourage you to give your parish priests more feedback when it comes to their preaching. Be kind, be brief and remember that most of them are doing the best they can. They have been raised up as priests in a system with literally no feedback.
Second, as you return to daily prayer, remember to ask the Lord to show you how to live out your faith. As you pour over the words of Scripture, ask the Lord to show you how it applies to your messy, beautiful daily life.
Show us Lord how to live like you…